Joe F. Carr Trophy

The Joe F. Carr Trophy was the first award given in the National Football League (NFL) to recognize a most valuable player for each season. It was first awarded in 1938, known then as the Gruen Trophy, and renamed in 1939 in honor of NFL commissioner Joseph Carr. The Gruen Trophy, sponsored by Gruen Watch Co., was first awarded in 1937 to Dutch Clark of the Detroit Lions. However, both contemporary and modern sources consider the 1938 award the first retroactive Joe F. Carr Trophy, and thus the first NFL MVP award. Players were chosen by a panel of sportswriters who distributed first and second place votes. It was awarded until the 1946 season, and it remains the only MVP award the NFL has officially sanctioned.

Season Player Team Position Refs
1938 Mel Hein New York Giants C, LB
1939 Parker Hall Cleveland Rams QB, HB
1940 Ace Parker Brooklyn Dodgers QB, HB
1941 Don Hutson Green Bay Packers End
1942 Don Hutson (2) Green Bay Packers End
1943 Sid Luckman Chicago Bears QB
1944 Frank Sinkwich Detroit Lions HB
1945 Bob Waterfield Cleveland Rams QB
1946 Bill Dudley Pittsburgh Steelers HB